New York City Council Investigates Marketing Practices of Kalshi and Other Platforms
New York City Council spokesperson Julie Menin announced the launch of an investigation into the marketing and advertising practices of four prediction market platforms: Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase, and Gemini Titan. The focus is on alleged false, deceptive, or abusive marketing strategies, particularly targeting young people.
Menin has sent formal letters to the four platforms requesting information on their marketing practices, including revenue scale in New York, the number of city resident users, and how they comply with consumer protection laws. The letters list over 60 questions and provide a 14-day response deadline. The council has been monitoring allegations of predatory marketing in the rapid expansion of this industry in New York City for months.
Specific allegations against Polymarket include paying social media creators to produce false trading videos, using fake websites that mimic the platform interface, showcasing bets that would actually incur losses but are presented as profitable, and promoting undisclosed influencer marketing related to insider trading. The council plans to hold a public hearing on this matter and assess whether there is a need to strengthen consumer protection, minor protection, and related legislation.
Coinbase responded that it offers prediction markets regulated by the CFTC and fully complies with applicable laws, while Polymarket expressed eagerness to communicate with the city council. This investigation comes amid ongoing lawsuits by the New York State Attorney General against some platforms for illegal gambling.
At the market mechanism level, event-driven regulatory pressure is prompting prediction market platforms to adjust their marketing and customer acquisition strategies, with funding and user growth potentially shifting from aggressive digital advertising to compliant channels. Beneficiaries will be platforms recognized by federal regulators, while those under pressure will be companies relying on young users and high-exposure marketing, leading to an overall funding flow that favors transaction volumes passing compliance reviews.
Source: Public Information
ABAB AI Insight
Kalshi previously received CFTC approval to operate event contracts, while Polymarket started as a crypto-native prediction market and quickly expanded into sports and political contracts. Coinbase and Gemini, as cryptocurrency exchanges, have extended their offerings with products like Titan, all having substantial business or headquarters ties in New York, facing ongoing litigation over conflicts between state gambling laws and federal commodity futures laws.
In terms of capital pathways, these platforms have invested resources in high-exposure digital advertising and influencer partnerships to rapidly acquire young users, motivated by the desire to hedge traditional crypto volatility with event contract trading volume. Strategically, they aim to lock in regulatory arbitrage windows through scaled user and data advantages, but their marketing investments have directly triggered local legislative scrutiny.
Similar cases include the New York State Attorney General's illegal gambling lawsuits against Coinbase and Gemini, as well as the CFTC's federal priority disputes over state enforcement. The industry is currently transitioning from disorderly expansion to a tightening of dual local and federal regulations.
Structural judgments indicate regulatory changes: local legislative bodies are intervening in the federal regulatory domain through marketing and consumer protection entry points. The mechanism allows city-level investigations and legislative hearings to be initiated quickly, bypassing state gambling law disputes and directly limiting customer acquisition costs, thereby altering the underlying customer acquisition structure that prediction markets rely on for growth among young users.
ABAB News · Cognitive Laws
Marketing is the entry point for regulation
The hotter the young traffic, the faster the scrutiny
Regulatory arbitrage will ultimately be priced by locals